Skip Navigation

The Problem with Communication

May 16, 2010 at 3:31 pm
By Sophie Bushwick

I was going to write about how there's too much to write about.  Well, not to much to write about, but too many places to write it.  I mean, if we want to discuss something serious, there's the Carletonian or one of the magazines, for random silliness we've got the Carl and the CLAP, and if we want to rant or just be opinionated, any of the above will do, depending on the amount of dirty language we want to throw around.  Then we have the DailyKnight, the newest addition to Carleton's many publications.

When I first heard about it, my first thought was "Really?  We have so many options when it comes to self-expression--do we need yet another forum to blast our opinions?"  After all, most of our "self-expression" ends up turning into complaints.  Complaints about college policies, about annoying habits, or even tirades against specific people who won't stop whistling or who didn't pay us back on time or who wronged us in some other way.  Life is never perfect, but it makes us feel better to be able to point out just what's wrong with it.  The problem is, complaining doesn't change things.  We're all too willing to offer criticism, but it's rarely constructive, and frequently serves solely to make us feel good about ourselves.

So, hypocritically, my solution to this problem was to complain.  I was ranting to a friend about our surplus of publication options, about to start in on something stupid I'd read, when she interrupted me.  "Are you kidding?  We don't have any publications that let us really communicate."  She pointed out the fact that none of our publications really provide a space for dialogue.  Sure, you could write a CLAP article in response to someone else, but those tend to instantly become pissing matches.  And without provoking conversation, an editorial rarely leads to the changes its writer wants.  When I read a complaint about noisy neighbors, I may agree that I get pissed off when my floor is too loud, but I'm unlikely to change my own habits to be quieter.  Nobody changes in response to someone else's complaints unless something personal is at stake, or their sympathy is provoked.  If we want to actually make changes, we should try to make issues personal for the intended audience, and the best way to do that is for them to answer back.  Opening up a dialogue allows us to improve ideas, connect with each other, and remind ourselves to treat our peers like fellow humans instead of yelling at them in print.

And that's why we need a blog!  Any comment section, if abused, can make the CLAP sound empathetic and thoughtful.  But if we actually want to make a difference, we need to not just blurt out our own ideas but to comment on others', to talk, to maintain a dialogue with other Carls.  And the DailyKnight isn't our only option!  The Carletonian is now online, and every article has an option for comments.  Respond to a Viewpoints piece, or even add some detail to a news article.  To deserve our reputation as a campus that cares about issues, and making life better, we need to do more than complain about our problems, even ones as minor as disrespectful neighbors.  In order to actually foment change, we need to communicate.

Bookmark this post on:

Digg logoDigg Delicious logoDelicious Reddit logoreddit StumbleUpon logoStumbleUpon


  • May 16 2010 at 3:45 pm
    Andy Rooks

    I totally agree. The quiet mutterings of students at Sayles after an inflammatory article is published deserve are too often unheard. My hope as an editor was to initiate some real open dialogue in a publication. Hooray web 2.0!

  • June 22 2010 at 7:45 am
    That's understandable that money makes us autonomous. But how to act if somebody does not have cash? The only one way is to get the mortgage loans and short term loan.
  • July 9 2010 at 3:43 pm
    Scott Donaldson

    Noelle that comment is just not helpful or even relevant. This article was not at all about having money, or not having money, or needing mortgage/short term loans. Now, I'm trying to start a dialog here with you, but I have to admit that I'm not exactly hopeful that you'll have anything worthwhile to say.

  • August 12 2010 at 4:52 am

    Tiffany And Co Jewellery: Find Online fashionable silver Tiffany, tiffany rings, necklaces,tiffany Pendants, earrings and Tiffany Bracelets at . Tiffany Jewellery

    Tiffany sale

    Tiffany Store Fashional Tiffany & CO. products about all Tiffany Jewellery, like: Tiffany Ring, Tiffany Necklaces, Tiffany Earrings, Tiffany Bracelets, Tiffany Necklaces

    Tiffany Charms

    Tiffany Bracelets

    Tiffany Earrings

    Tiffany Rings


    Tiffany and Co provide more styles tiffany necklaces,rings and bracelets with your choice,love in tiffany jewellery

  • September 24 2010 at 12:59 am
    ugg bailey button

    First, thanks for giving me opportunity to comment on, thank you. Really well written article, I also like. In addition, a message attached:At the same time ,you will be fashion in the cold weater.The ugg bailey button is now available at, As bailey button uggs are so distinctive from classic bailey button ugg boots, thanks to their attractive side split and distinctive ugg bailey button boots bomber you're bound to stand out from the crowd when you buy a pair. All womens bailey button uggs in our Classic collection feature a soft foam insole covered with ugg bailey button boots at macys and have a light and flexible outsole designed for amazing comfort with every step. Incredibly versatile, you can wear ugg bailey button boot at calf length like the discount ugg bailey button, or turn them down for an ugg bailey button boots trendy look that will be the envy of all your friends.

  • September 24 2010 at 1:00 am
    Air Jordans

    One thing that I like from coach products for summer footwear is Air Jordans.When the summer season comes, most people both men and women are looking for Coach Bags great fashion accessories including footwear. Jordan Shoes is offering the great summer footwear air yeezy for men and women with great style and high quality products. Italian loafers are designed by famous Italian fashion designers with high quality material and well craftsmanship. Most of Italian Coach Outlet Store are made of the leather which is the best material for the fashion accessories including footwear air yeezy shoes like loafer.

  • September 24 2010 at 1:00 am
    nike air yeezy

    Coach loafers are designed to be perfect summer footwear for men and women. There are many options of Air Jordan Shoes available on Cheap Coach or even online shopping stores with great selection and price range offered. It is always good idea to have a great collection of nike air yeezy products like Nike Air Jordan, coach shoes, coach sunglasses, Coach Purses and more. Italian leather is maintained to be one of the best leather in the world that many people use it for the handbags, wallets, shoes and many more.You will be more fashionable if you can combine them into your fashion style.Italian leather nike yeezy come in amazing quality that you can rely on

  • September 24 2010 at 1:15 am
    yeezy shoes

    They are very elegant and beautiful Nike Air Jordan Shoes to wear around the summer time. You can wear them with jeans, shorts or even yeezy shoes. You can use it to go for shopping, lunch, beach or even spending days at the down town.Summer time is always very fascinating season for most of us. So, don't you even miss to enjoy the summer vacation with great fashion accessories from air yeezys products? You don't have to stick on Coach Handbags or coach sandals! You can also get Coach Outlet Store for better style and comfort as the products are meant to be.Michael Jordan Shoes come in different style and collection which will give you more option to choose.

  • October 7 2010 at 3:31 am
    Christian Louboutin
    It is named Christian Louboutin for the reason that man who create Christian Louboutin shoes. At the same time, it's helpful to reduce the risk of injury for the player. If you think your feet should be protected well during the strenuous exercise, the Christian Louboutin Pumps are the right choice for you. There are many Cheap Christian Louboutin Heels from our shop. If you want to learn more informations of those Christian Louboutin Boots, please visite our website Are you looking for a comfortable shoes? We are ready for you to give you great discount Christian Louboutin Sandals and best service.
  • October 7 2010 at 3:31 am
    UGG Boots
    If you are looking for a pair of pretty UGG Boots, you shouldn't miss this chance for purchasing UGG Classic Cardy Boots this season in our shop. Ugg Bailey Button would give people such a deep impression. UGG Classic Short Boots appreciate it not only by the high quality with steady innovations but also by its stylish designs. There is no doubt that it could go well with you casual outfits. There are many kinds of UGG Classic Tall Boots for different ages and tastes online. So pick up your own UGG Sandals now.
  • October 7 2010 at 3:32 am
    Supra shoes
    With the high-tech Supra Shoes technology and unique colorways design, it can make you more special in the crowd. Now you can choose whatever you like on our Supra Footwear shop. Supra Skytop, the colorway of shoes is just right, which can stimulate your passion for sport availably. Those great quality but Supra TK Society are waiting for you right now. There will always be one pair of shoes appropriated for you on our Supra Sneakers store.
  • October 8 2010 at 3:10 am
    gucci shoes

    do you want to buy gucci shoes ?gucci outlet online have many cheap gucci shoes for you.

  • October 9 2010 at 3:21 am
    Christian Louboutin

    Christian Louboutin is renowned for designing classy dressy high heels with embellishments such as straps adorned with jewels, bows and feathers. More and more woman makes frenzy love into the Christian Louboutin Heels. Wearing high-heeled shoes,let a woman double self-confidence. Christian Louboutin Sandals will be another area trend fashion shoes. Christian Louboutin Pumps mesh ring has swept the world for their femininity,and Christian Louboutin Boots are also very popular,they have the highest quality and beautiful designs.So Choose a pair of Classic Christian Louboutin Shoes, except for yourself to consider shoe body styles and fabrics, shoes and heel modeling also reveal personality of ego is very important.

  • October 9 2010 at 3:22 am
    UGG Boots

    UGG Boots from The North Face are dependable, durable, and high-quality. The traditional distinctive ugg styles like UGG Classic Tall Boots and UGG Classic Short Boots with the top that can be folded either up or down is still hugely popular in multi-hues. The chief integrity of the film Titanic is not an omission since it also looks funny for UGG Classic Cardy Boots to look on other men's feet. Ugg Bailey Button sale online is also very versatile as it can be worn up or olded down for a different look. The Ugg Sandals are made with special quality materials as a result of which they can make the wearer feel absolutely comfortable in any situation and any occasion.

  • October 11 2010 at 12:37 pm
    Have no enough money to buy a house? You should not worry, because this is real to receive the personal loans to resolve such kind of problems. Thence take a credit loan to buy everything you need.
  • October 13 2010 at 2:12 am

    I know that dialog is important and you just don't get it in print. Even if you get some comments that may not be relevant, at least the door is open on a blog. Comments may be the only way people can communicate. I know that it is sometimes hard to weed out the good from the bad (mostly it just takes time) but it is worthwhile. I know on my <a href="">dark chocolate</a> blog, a day doesn't go by that I'm not there going through a comment or trackback. But it does add to the viability and spurs on ideas and idea exchange.

  • October 13 2010 at 2:13 am

    I know that dialog is important and you just don't get it in print. Even if you get some comments that may not be relevant, at least the door is open on a blog. Comments may be the only way people can communicate. I know that it is sometimes hard to weed out the good from the bad (mostly it just takes time) but it is worthwhile. I know on my <a href="">dark chocolate</a> blog, a day doesn't go by that I'm not there going through a comment or trackback. But it does add to the viability and spurs on ideas and idea exchange.

  • October 17 2010 at 10:08 pm
    moncler sale

    Heating experiment is a moncler long waiting process that requires discount moncler jackets persistence and perseverance, while also note that moncler jackets method, first stir a slow fire, after the moncler sale last use of waste heat evaporated to get crystals. Not only the warmth of the small monlcer online store family business, but also make contributions to society.

  • October 18 2010 at 9:08 pm

    I saw something shocking on my way to work the other day. uggs new york While bundled in a long sleeved shirt, wool sweater and coat, with a Pashmina, hat and gloves, I saw a man with his bike a the bus stop in SANDALS. He wasn’t overly well dressed for cold weather, in jeans, t-shirt and open jacket. Now, having lived in Oregon for the past decade I have come to be aware of what “true Oregonians” consider winter attire. This primarily consists of the inbred belief that flip-flops are a necessity year round, and sweaters and umbrellas are for tourists.I do not uphold this belief. I love getting dressed up for winter, layering on leggings with my sweater dress and ugg boots new york, a sweater and a jacket, and a rotating army of scarves, hats and gloves. I don’t enjoy being frozen, especially knowing how easy a situation that is to avoid. uggs new york saleSo personally, I do not consider myself a “true Oregonian.” I like umbrellas, and only wear flip flops when it’s above 75 degrees.Based on the population of Oregon, ugg new york I’m probably in the minority. Although I have come to accept that these people are just immune to cold in a way I am not, uggs new york of sale I do still think they are crazy. I’m guessing that the good folks at UGG Australia caught wind of these people because look at what they have to offer: sandals with fleece!uggs new york on sale

  • October 20 2010 at 6:25 am
    the north face jacket

Posted In